Challenge Disparity, Build Diversity

Dear Members of the Western New York Legal Community:

We are now into the sixth month of the COVID-19 era, and the future remains uncertain. Over the past few months, we have been impressed with the local courts’ and bar’s ability to shift to remote work and virtual meetings and hearings. However, as the courts expand operations and the economy slowly reopens, we want to remind everyone that COVID-19 closures and health risks continue to affect lawyers, clients, and witnesses and that these effects have fallen disproportionately on women and people of color.

The pandemic and resulting economic downturn have exposed and exacerbated the inequities that women and minorities experience on a daily basis. In early summer, the Western New York Women’s Foundation documented COVID-19’s effect on working women. The documented effects will continue into the fall. Most schools are reopening either virtually or on a hybrid schedule, and there is limited availability of low-cost childcare. While we recognize that all working parents will need flexible working arrangements, as shown in the Western New York Women’s Foundation study, the COVID-19 pandemic has disparately impacted working women. In other words, women need the profession as a whole to recognize that they are performing the challenging task of doing two jobs at once.

In addition, limitations on in-person attendance at the New York State Bar Exam are disproportionately affecting bar takers of color. This compounds a pre-existing problem: due to the expense of bar exam study and preparation materials (and technology such as an up to date computer), many students of color do not have equitable access to these study aids and, as a result, some do not pass the bar exam the first time. We do not yet know whether the economic collapse will adversely affect diversity enrollment in law school.

Our organizations together recognize that the legal profession is stronger when women and attorneys of color are actively engaged. Studies show that increased representation of women and people of color in leadership is associated with increased profitability and responsiveness to client demands. In other words, women and attorneys of color are crucial to the legal profession, and it is critical that COVID-19 not impede or delay programs and funding that address making our ranks more diverse and inclusive.

Therefore, we are calling on the legal profession as a whole to support our working parents and to recognize the hurdles people of color face to advancement in our profession. Employers must support flexible working arrangements. Colleagues, including opposing counsel and the courts, must be flexible and creative with scheduling. Opportunities for success and advancement must remain open to women and people of color, notwithstanding temporary adjustments to the demands of COVID-19.

And we must now all seize the opportunity to prioritize diversity and mitigate COVID-19’s effects. We encourage you to provide internships to law students and seek out women and students of color as part of your outreach for prospective candidates. You may contact Vice Dean Lisa Patterson at UB Law School to find a law student intern at 716.645.6262 or lpatter@buffalo.edu. It is also important to provide college students with internship opportunities during this time. The Say Yes college internship program is looking for local firms, non-profits and government organizations to hire interns this fall. We urge all employers to consider hiring a Say Yes intern and to provide a positive office experience to hardworking and bright young college students who may become hard working and bright young attorneys. Please reach out to Stephanie Peete at 716.335.7520 or speete@sayyesbuffalo.org to find a Say Yes intern.

Finally, we challenge each member of our profession to take the Pledge to “Challenge Disparity, Build Diversity.” Below is the pledge in full, and a place where you can sign the pledge. Together we are stronger; together we can make a difference.

This initiative is brought to you by the following organizations

Minority Bar Association

Board Resolution

Whereas, COVID-19 has a demonstrably disparate impact on women lawyers, lawyers of color, and law students of color;

Whereas, the BAEC believes that a diversified bar in all aspects of our profession is a stronger bar now and in the future;

Whereas, diversifying the practicing bar in Erie County is a core value of the BAEC and central to fulfilling our mission;

Whereas, the BAEC believes that raising awareness of the disparate impact of COVID-19 on women  lawyers, lawyers of color and law students of color will help mitigate actions that adversely affect these affected groups;

Therefore, it is hereby resolved:

The BAEC encourages all of its members to recognize and educate others about the disparate impact of COVID-19 on women lawyers, lawyers of color, and law students of color.

The BAEC supports scheduling the NYS Bar Exam to accommodate non-first-time takers.

The BAEC supports flexibility and civility in scheduling matters with opposing counsel and employees during this pandemic.

The BAEC encourages firms and employers to remain committed to diversity in hiring and promotions during COVID-19, including partnerships and internships and to take a pledge to do so and promote that pledge, Challenge Disparity, Build Diversity.;

The BAEC shall hire a Say Yes Intern.

The BAEC shall create and support a giving circle philanthropy program that will be dedicated to providing funds to support the advancement of women lawyers, lawyers of color, and law students of color in the law.

Take the Pledge

I pledge to…

  • Actively identify and address issues of disparity involving women attorneys and attorneys of color in my spheres of influence.
  • Design and participate in initiatives within my law firm or other place of employment that address issues of disparity against women attorneys and attorneys of color.
  • Participate in the Western New York legal community’s efforts to address issues of disparity and increase diversity and inclusion.
  • Support my colleagues, financially or otherwise, in their efforts to implement the Pledge.

Challenge Disparity, Build Diversity

I pledge to…
• Actively identify and address issues of disparity involving women attorneys and attorneys of color in my spheres of influence.
• Design and participate in initiatives within my law firm or other place of employment that addresses issues of disparity against women attorneys and attorneys of color.
• Participate in the Western New York legal community’s efforts to address issues of disparity and increase diversity and inclusion.
• Support my colleagues, financially or otherwise, in their efforts to implement the pledge.

%%your signature%%

180 signatures

Spread the word! Let the world know you took the pledge by adding the Challenge Disparity graphic to your email signature (and anywhere else you want to put it)! Encourage your friends and colleagues to do the same!

Pledge Signees

Eric Bernhardt
Craig Bucki
Oliver Young
Ralph L. Halpern
Sharon Stern Gerstman
Joseph mccarthy
Timothy Graber
Lauren Breen
Julie Bastian
Timothy Hoover
Sharon LoVallo
Sarah O’Brien
Anna Marie Richmond
Kristen Kozlowski
John DiMaio
Patrick Hines
Andrew Freedman
Elizabeth Buscaglia
Leslie Kellogg
Pauline Muto
Ari Goldberg
Meghan Dwyer
Andrew Carroll
Susan Benz
Christopher Cardillo
Lisa Zaccagnino
Carol Snider
Samantha Podlas
Corey Auerbach
Paul Bartlett
Mark McNamara
Gregory Zini
Peter Marlette
Chris Berloth
Tomas Callocchia
Katelynn Johnson
George Collins
Scott Corathers
Margaret Phillips
Sidney Mosher
Sean Balkin
Dennis Bischof
Mary Balkin
Nicole Komin
Kelly Barrett Sarama
Alex Kaczmarek
Patrick Kenney
Marissa Wickett
Lindsay Lougen
Tyler O’Neill
Amy Hemenway
Renee Heitger
Marissa Washington
Anne Downey
Fred Gawronski
Kimberly Cline
Anna McCarthy
Edward Stone
Paul Buchanan
Natalie Lesniak
Kara Addelman
John Horn
Colleen Gable
Maria Valeri
Shelby Scibetta
Sara Stoessel
Hilary Banker
Melinda Saran
Colleen Gough
Lisa Coppola
Howard Rosenhoch
Jody Briandi
Marci Wiseman
Gretchen Gonzalez
Brenda Cisneros Vilchis
Dalya Kefi
Tim OMara
Robert Elardo
Terry Connors
Edward Robinson
Ann Evanko
Dan Kohane
Marina Barci
Michael Roach
Katelyn Niedermier
Daniel Marren
Roslyn McLin
Ashley Lowry
Kara Eyre
Jessie Senske
Alan Carrel
Robert Heary
Kathleen Carmody
Samuel Alba
Karen Richardson
Ilene Fleischmann
David Schopp
Victoria DAngelo
Elizabeth Ingold
Leonardo Sette-Camara
Kelley Omel
Reetuparna Dutta
Charles Carra
Brian Welsh
Carolyn DeVaughn
Jim Schultz
Mary Kohlbacher
Kathleen Sellers
Aimee Hopkins
Miranda Jakubec
David Pfalzgraf
Anne Bowling
Bridget O’Connell
Heather Abraham
Franklin Heller
Harry Meyer
Amber Storr
Rebecca Stadler
Lisa Bloch Rodwin
Glenn Speller
Katie Martin
Linda Grear
Heather Gresham
Daniel Coleman
Susan Kohlbacher
Leanna Pilarski
Peter Crotty
Jennifer Leonardi
Keli Iles-Hernandez
Marianne Mariano
Anaiss Rijo
Stephanie McCance
Mary Carney
Lisa Patterson
Tim Andruschat
Michelle Parker
Robert Brucato
Gayle Murphy
Stephanie Calhoun
Sharon Nosenchuck
Mary Moorman Penn
Barbara Howe
Jennifer Kimura
John Aman
Jamila Lee
Anne Joynt
Doris Carbonell-Medina
Hugh Russ
Christopher Phillips
Daniel Ortega
Ann Nichols
Megan Gomez
Andrea Schillaci
Liz Midgley
Anne Noble
Elizabeth Kraengel
Greg Hirtzel

Add the Graphic to Your Email Signature

There are 2 versions of the graphic available for download. Click the button next to the graphic you want to use to download the graphic file.

How to add graphic to your email signature

(Graphic can only be added to desktop versions of your email. Your email app on your smartphone does not allow for images.)

Microsoft Outlook

Apple Mail

Gmail

Need additional help?

Email Greg Hirtzel by clicking here.

Challenge Disparity, Build Diversity